Society for the Advancement of Psychotherapy

When It Is Not a Good Fit

David Kealy, Ph.D.John S. Ogrodniczuk, Ph.D.William E. PiperCarlos A. Sierra-Hernandez

David Kealy, Ph.D. & 3 others

September 19, 2016

When It Is Not a Good Fit

Abstract

Group psychotherapy provides unique opportunities for clinical errors in the selection of patients and composition of therapy groups. This article introduces some of the difficulties and complexities that can be associated with group composition and patient selection errors. Clinical vignettes from psychodynamic/interpersonal psychotherapy groups are used to illustrate three variations of group composition and selection errors. The first vignette depicts an error in selecting a disruptive patient into a fledgling group. The second vignette portrays an unsuccessful integration of a withdrawn, inhibited patient into an active, exploratory group. The third scenario illustrates challenges associated with poor quality of object relations in homogeneous group composition. Although research on group therapy composition and patient selection is limited, relevant empirical literature is integrated in our discussion of clinical implications and recommendations.

Keywords: group psychotherapy, clinical errors, patient selection, group composition

About the Author

David Kealy, Ph.D.

David Kealy, Ph.D.

Dr. David Kealy is an Associate Professor with the Psychotherapy Program and the Institute of Mental Health. Dr. Kealy has a background in social work and public mental health service, previously holding a clinical leadership position at one of the largest community outpatient psychotherapy programs in British Columbia. He provides teaching and clinical supervision in the Psychotherapy Program, and maintains an active consultation and psychotherapy practice.

Citation

Kealy, D., Ogrodniczuk, J. S., Piper, W. E., & Sierra-Hernandez, C. A. (2016). When it is not a good fit: Clinical errors in patient selection and group composition in group psychotherapy.Psychotherapy, 53(3), 308-313.

References

No references.